We tend to experience our feelings one at a time: happy or sad, hopeful or afraid, grateful or angry, coping or ... not. It seems simple and obvious. But life has an inconvenient habit of refusing to organize itself quite so neatly.
Sometimes we can be enormously grateful for what we have and still grieve what we have lost. We can receive good news and still be frightened. We can know how fortunate we are and still find something incredibly hard. We can laugh until our sides hurt in the middle of a time we would never have chosen for ourselves.
One feeling does not necessarily cancel out the other, and yet, sometimes we behave as though it should. We tell ourselves we shouldn’t be upset because someone else has it worse. We feel guilty for enjoying ourselves when something difficult is happening, or for struggling when there is so much we know we should be grateful for.
At times like that, the simple question, “How are you?”, can become surprisingly difficult.
What is the answer when you are doing well and not doing well at exactly the same time? When there are things to celebrate and things you are quietly carrying? We tend to reach for one answer, perhaps because it is easier to give and certainly easier to explain. “I’m good.” “It’s hard.” “I’m fine.”
But perhaps the problem isn’t the contradiction, but our expectation that there shouldn’t be one. We like to make sense of how we feel. We look for the dominant emotion, the one that tells us how we are “really” doing. But sometimes there isn’t one. Sometimes the most truthful answer is complicated.
Gratitude does not require us to pretend something doesn’t hurt. Fear does not mean we have given up hope. Having a terrible day doesn’t mean we are failing to cope, just as having a wonderful one doesn’t mean everything is suddenly fine. There is room for more than one truth. And that matters particularly when life gets complicated, because trying to decide which feeling we are supposed to have can become yet another thing to carry.
We don’t have to choose between acknowledging what is difficult and appreciating what is good. We don’t have to diminish our own experience because someone else’s is harder. And we don’t have to turn every good moment into evidence that we are doing brilliantly. We can simply let each moment be what it is, even when what it is doesn’t fit neatly into one box.
A hard day can contain something wonderful and a good day can contain something difficult. We can be grateful and grieving, hopeful and scared, laughing and struggling.
Two things can be true.
Sometimes, even more.